Resources > Articles

Ask the Experts: Who is accountable for product defects?

Pragmatic Institute Logo and 3 verticals

In my experience, “defects” actually fall into two categories. The first group represents things that work exactly as we designed them to work, but that people feel don’t work correctly. In other words, they aren’t broken, they just aren’t very good. These actually aren’t defects at all; they are poorly designed features. They should be captured and added to the list of things we need to do. Whoever owns the “to-do” lists (enhancements, new ideas, product roadmap) should add these improvements to the list. Generally, that’s product management. Those items need to be analyzed, reviewed and prioritized along with everything else on the list.

The second kind of defect is one where the product doesn’t work as designed. In other words, it is broken. If it adds a column of numbers and gets the wrong result, that is a defect. In those cases, these items shouldn’t have to get in line or be analyzed or prioritized. They should be fixed. Development should own these, assess how the defect happened and fix it as soon as possible. Once that’s completed, product management should be involved in deciding when to deliver a fix to the market.

One more comment: If the second type of defect is a common occurrence, it could be a quality issue. Usually, quality is a policy issue, a function of management policy and standards. Some companies have a zero defect policy, resulting in high-cost—and sometimes much slower—development processes. Others choose lower costs or quicker delivery as a policy objective, sometimes resulting in quality issues. Should you start to see a growing number of defects, it may be time to look more closely at your policies.

Author
  • Rich Nutinsky

    Rich Nutinsky is a master instructor at Pragmatic Institute, with more than 20 years of experience in the software industry. He has launched several successful software products using the Pragmatic Institute Framework. Prior to joining Pragmatic Institute, Rich served in various management and product management positions for companies including Arasys Technologies, where he was vice president of product management and development. He has provided consulting services to market leaders such as Microsoft, AT&T, DuPont, NEC, GE and Siemens, working with senior-level executives to improve their product strategy, product management and marketing processes. He may be reached at [email protected].

Author:

Other Resources in this Series

Most Recent

Is Your Training Budget Going to Waste?
Article

Is Your Training Budget Going to Waste? How to Calculate Training ROI 

The latest report from Training magazine has some news – U.S. companies have, for the first time, spent over $100 billion on training.  So, why the big spend? In the fast-paced, competitive business world, companies...
: OpenAI's ChatGPT Enterprise Takes Center Stage
Article

How ChatGPT Enterprise Addresses Key Concerns in Generative AI

OpenAI just released ChatGPT Enterprise, a business-oriented upgrade of its popular AI chatbot—make no mistake, this is a big deal. 
AI and Product Management
Article

AI and Product Management: Navigating Ethical Considerations 

Explore the critical aspects of AI product management, its challenges, and strategies for ensuring responsible and successful implementation.
How to learn AI for Product Managers
Article

How to Learn AI as a Product Manager: Start Here 

As a product manager, harnessing the power of AI can be a game-changer for your product. Whether automating mundane tasks, providing personalized experiences or making data-driven decisions, AI has many applications that can propel your...
Category: AI
Article

Beyond SEO: Driving Customer Attraction, Retention and Top-Line Growth

Does your website speak to your customers and fulfill your business objectives?

OTHER ArticleS

Is Your Training Budget Going to Waste?
Article

Is Your Training Budget Going to Waste? How to Calculate Training ROI 

The latest report from Training magazine has some news – U.S. companies have, for the first time, spent over $100 billion on training.  So, why the big spend? In the fast-paced, competitive business world, companies...
: OpenAI's ChatGPT Enterprise Takes Center Stage
Article

How ChatGPT Enterprise Addresses Key Concerns in Generative AI

OpenAI just released ChatGPT Enterprise, a business-oriented upgrade of its popular AI chatbot—make no mistake, this is a big deal. 

Sign up to stay up to date on the latest industry best practices.

Sign up to received invites to upcoming webinars, updates on our recent podcast episodes and the latest on industry best practices.

Subscribe

Subscribe

Training on Your Schedule

Fill out the form today and our sales team will help you schedule your private Pragmatic training today.