Resources > Articles

Intellectual Property: The 7 Deadly Myths

Post Author
  • Dinos Gonatas holds a PhD in physics from the University of Chicago and a bachelor?s degree from Princeton University, and he has participated in executive education at the Babson College of Business and the Wharton School. His consultancy, CPG Advisors, focuses on IP and new technology commercialization. His expertise is in intellectual property management and business development, with an industry focus in high technology, communications and instrumentation. He also is an inventor, holding eight patents in synthetic fuel processing and thermal catalysis. He can be reached at dinos.gonatas@gmail.com.

property

When product executives get together, we’re usually preoccupied with urgent tasks: pricing and positioning, new introductions, social networks, voice of customer, Agile development, etc. We tend to neglect non-urgent issues, even if they have long-term value potential. Intellectual property (IP) is only discussed now and then.

At one former employer, my chief technology officer even took it a step beyond neglect, saying he didn’t want his team reading competitors’ patents—and risking subconscious copying. Then he stated one of the seven common myths about intellectual property.

Myth 1: Even if you can get a patent, technology moves too quickly for it to be important. In fact, the fast-moving tech industry has as many patent assertion actions as all industries put together. Consider these headlines:

  • Jury awards Apple $1.049 billion in Samsung patent dispute ruling” – The Verge, 8/24/12. (It has since been reduced to $600 million.)
  • Microsoft Owes Up to $600 million Over Patent Use” – Bloomberg, 3/23/09
  • A10 Networks enjoined from selling ADCs infringing Brocade patents” – Network World, 1/11/13
  • Broadcom Granted Permanent Injunction Against Emulex in Patent Infringement Suit”  – PR Newswire, 3/20/12

The last two items carry an especially scary message: If you infringe on a competitor’s patent, they can apply for a court

order preventing you from selling your product. Complying can mean a big waste of time and money reengineering the product. In a worst-case scenario, it could mean killing your product altogether.

In brief, a patent has a description of the invention, drawings and claims that set forth specifically what is covered. It can be a new device, a composition of matter or method. There are also special “design patents” that cover industrial designs and decorations, like those rounded corners on the iPhone.

A patent entitles the holder to sue infringers and nothing more. If the holder prevails, they can usually obtain an injunction preventing further infringement and monetary damages covering the value of the business the infringer won attributable to the technology. Note that companies are only entitled to damages covering prior infringement if the product is clearly marked as patented, along with the patent numbers. It’s the product team’s responsibility to ensure all physical products are marked and all software lists the patent numbers (usually in the manuals or in the “About” drop-down menu).

Let’s look at some of the other misconceptions about patents and intellectual property.

Myth 2: You can’t get a patent on software. While you can’t get a patent for an abstract idea like E=MC2 or a new algorithm to convert octal into decimal numbers, you can generally get a patent on a method deployed in a computer that does something useful. For example, a new type of graphical user interface, a method for evaluating computer code or parallel processing of data arrays.

Myth 3: Don’t bother to get a patent; it costs too much to enforce. While it can cost a bundle to defend a patent case—as much as $6 million to pursue a final verdict if a prestigious top-dollar law firm is chosen—patents are rarely litigated. A primary objective is deterrence or bargaining leverage, as seen in this heavy-handed email from Steve Jobs to the president of Palm, Ed Colligan. The email followed a phone call threatening to sue Palm for patent litigation.

Author

  • Dinos Gonatas holds a PhD in physics from the University of Chicago and a bachelor?s degree from Princeton University, and he has participated in executive education at the Babson College of Business and the Wharton School. His consultancy, CPG Advisors, focuses on IP and new technology commercialization. His expertise is in intellectual property management and business development, with an industry focus in high technology, communications and instrumentation. He also is an inventor, holding eight patents in synthetic fuel processing and thermal catalysis. He can be reached at dinos.gonatas@gmail.com.

Author:

Other Resources in this Series

Most Recent

A dashboard on a website showcasing product management measurement
Article

Measurement-Driven Product Management

If you are a vice president, director or team leader for a product management function, one of the biggest challenges you face today is how to demonstrate the team is making a significant contribution to top line or bottom line targets. If you can’t measure your team’s effectiveness, or if you are focused on the wrong metrics, your headcount and budget allocation could be at risk.

Product life cycle: Introduction, Growth, Maturity, Decline
Article

23 Metrics Mapped to the Product Life Cycle

Learn what to measure and how to avoid vanity metrics during each stage of the product life cycle: development, launch, growth, maturity and decline. Also learn the difference between a mission and objective and how to identify which stage your product is in.
ROI of being market driven. An image with illustration dollar signs
Article

The ROI of Being Market-Driven

Market-driven companies are more profitable, twice as fast in getting new products to market, and have higher customer satisfaction levels.
Article

23 Metrics Mapped to Each Stage of the User Journey

23 metrics for the user journey, which is the path a user takes while interacting with your product (sometimes called a flow funnel).
A person holding up a sign that say who is responsible
Article

Product Marketing or Product Management

Roles Before Titles The job titles of product marketing manager and product manager are confusing enough to start raging debates about who does what. Organizations often transpose the job titles, adding to the confusion. This article

OTHER ArticleS

A dashboard on a website showcasing product management measurement
Article

Measurement-Driven Product Management

If you are a vice president, director or team leader for a product management function, one of the biggest challenges you face today is how to demonstrate the team is making a significant contribution to top line or bottom line targets. If you can’t measure your team’s effectiveness, or if you are focused on the wrong metrics, your headcount and budget allocation could be at risk.

Product life cycle: Introduction, Growth, Maturity, Decline
Article

23 Metrics Mapped to the Product Life Cycle

Learn what to measure and how to avoid vanity metrics during each stage of the product life cycle: development, launch, growth, maturity and decline. Also learn the difference between a mission and objective and how to identify which stage your product is in.

Sign up to stay up to date on the latest industry best practices.

Sign up to received invites to upcoming webinars, updates on our recent podcast episodes and the latest on industry best practices.

Training on Your Schedule

Fill out the form today and our sales team will help you schedule your private Pragmatic training today.

Subscribe

Subscribe

Training on Your Schedule

Fill out the form today and our sales team will help you schedule your private Pragmatic training today.