Resources > Articles

How to Use Win/Loss Analysis to Plug Top-Of-Funnel Leaks

Post Author
  • Pragmatic Institute is the transformational partner for today’s businesses, providing immediate impact through actionable and practical training for product, design and data teams. Our courses are taught by industry experts with decades of hands-on experience, and include a complete ecosystem of training, resources and community. This focus on dynamic instruction and continued learning has delivered impactful education to over 200,000 alumni worldwide over the last 30 years.

product marketing funnel

By Willem Maas

 

A CMO client of ours was having a problem with disappearing leads. She was at 50% of her pipeline contribution target and needed to understand why so many of her MQLs were dropping out before engaging with sales.

product marketing funnel

For another client, the problem was too many prospects dropping out after participating in a trial for their SaaS analytics offering.

Both clients asked us why these prospects were disappearing from the funnel?

Today, without in-person meetings and conferences, it’s become significantly harder and more expensive to build a B2B pipeline. The CAC [Customer Acquisition Cost] ratio for new customers has increased 18.5% over 2019, according to KeyBanc’s 2020 Private SaaS Company Survey.

So losing leads like the two clients mentioned above has become a more concerning problem.

So, as a product marketer, what can you do to help? Have you updated your targeting and messaging this year? If not, here’s some helpful advice about how you can use win/loss data to improve your targeting and plug up those leaks in your funnel.

 

Find The Leaks

Using your data to identify leaks in the funnel is the essential first step to plugging them.

To spot problem areas, compare current conversion rates to historical conversion rates. Or compare current conversion rates to your internal targets for this offering.

Getting that data can be as easy as checking a dashboard or may require running a report in your marketing automation system or CRM.

The table below lists critical top- and mid-funnel conversion points and includes benchmark conversion rates for a midmarket or enterprise offering.

This data is a starting point. Your own historical conversion rates and targets will make better benchmarks because conversion varies by domain and ACV (annual contract value).

 

Four Steps To Understanding Why Prospects Are Dropping Out

Once a critical dropoff point has been identified, interview prospects who dropped out at that point to understand the causes.

These prospects may be dropping out to pursue a purchase with another vendor, build their own solution, or “do nothing.”

In essence, we slide our methodology for win/loss analysis (helpful how-to guide here) up the funnel to analyze the critical dropoff point. Instead of interviewing buyers in closed/won and closed/lost opportunities, we’re debriefing prospects who dropped out at the top of the funnel. Either they declined the Sales Development Rep’s offer of an initial meeting (conversation-to-meeting). Or they dropped out after an initial meeting with sales, before converting into an opportunity.

Then we use a four-step process to acquire and analyze the data:

  1. Once we’ve agreed to prioritize a critical dropoff point, we build a list of prospects who have effectively said “no” at that conversion point—either through direct contact with front-line people or by becoming unresponsive.
  2. We present a research opportunity to these exact prospects that dropped out, using targeted ads on Linkedin or Facebook. Or, as an independent researcher, we email them directly.
  3. We interview them about the perceptions and preferences they developed during the buying journey, using a documentary film metaphor to help them open up and tell their story.
  4. We identify the principal reasons prospects are “dropping out” by coding and analyzing the interviews to find patterns that explain the behavior.

 

How it Works

For the first client we mentioned earlier, their prospects were dropping out because they couldn’t find peers who had used the vendor’s product. They told us that they had tried finding someone to talk to in their network about the product, but when they didn’t find anyone, they put the purchase on the backburner. The issue wasn’t a negative experience—it was no experience.

For the second client, our research uncovered that they were losing prospects to a dominant competitor’s “good enough” alternative product. The benefits of switching weren’t immediately obvious during a trial, and the vendor’s positioning wasn’t motivating prospective buyers to make the effort to switch. Many prospects simply added another module from the competitor’s platform to solve their problem, instead of investing in a new product.

Our interviews uncovered the most common decision criteria used by buyers in this category and readily observable drawbacks to the competitor’s offering for each of them. This became the jumping-off point for the client. Their marketing team used these insights to reposition the competitor, and updated the messaging used by sales, a battle card for sales reps, and a “comparison page” on the website.

 

The Top Of The Funnel Has Stolen The Spotlight

The pandemic has upended a longstanding attention bias. In the past, late-stage deals have gotten much more attention than early-stage ones, or prospecting. But this year that’s changed.

Today, without in-person meetings and conferences, it’s become significantly harder and more expensive to build a pipeline. The top of the funnel is now getting renewed attention. New ideas, energy, and focus from marketing and sales leadership is flowing into the top of the funnel. As product marketers, we need to help.

 

About the author

Willem Maas has led product marketing and product management at both startups and major companies. He’s also a three-time startup founder and CEO (one acquisition). He’s now president of consulting firm Growth Velocity Corp.

Author

  • Pragmatic Institute is the transformational partner for today’s businesses, providing immediate impact through actionable and practical training for product, design and data teams. Our courses are taught by industry experts with decades of hands-on experience, and include a complete ecosystem of training, resources and community. This focus on dynamic instruction and continued learning has delivered impactful education to over 200,000 alumni worldwide over the last 30 years.

Author:

Other Resources in this Series

Most Recent

A dashboard on a website showcasing product management measurement
Article

Measurement-Driven Product Management

If you are a vice president, director or team leader for a product management function, one of the biggest challenges you face today is how to demonstrate the team is making a significant contribution to top line or bottom line targets. If you can’t measure your team’s effectiveness, or if you are focused on the wrong metrics, your headcount and budget allocation could be at risk.

Product life cycle: Introduction, Growth, Maturity, Decline
Article

23 Metrics Mapped to the Product Life Cycle

Learn what to measure and how to avoid vanity metrics during each stage of the product life cycle: development, launch, growth, maturity and decline. Also learn the difference between a mission and objective and how to identify which stage your product is in.
ROI of being market driven. An image with illustration dollar signs
Article

The ROI of Being Market-Driven

Market-driven companies are more profitable, twice as fast in getting new products to market, and have higher customer satisfaction levels.
Article

23 Metrics Mapped to Each Stage of the User Journey

23 metrics for the user journey, which is the path a user takes while interacting with your product (sometimes called a flow funnel).
A person holding up a sign that say who is responsible
Article

Product Marketing or Product Management

Roles Before Titles The job titles of product marketing manager and product manager are confusing enough to start raging debates about who does what. Organizations often transpose the job titles, adding to the confusion. This article

OTHER ArticleS

A dashboard on a website showcasing product management measurement
Article

Measurement-Driven Product Management

If you are a vice president, director or team leader for a product management function, one of the biggest challenges you face today is how to demonstrate the team is making a significant contribution to top line or bottom line targets. If you can’t measure your team’s effectiveness, or if you are focused on the wrong metrics, your headcount and budget allocation could be at risk.

Product life cycle: Introduction, Growth, Maturity, Decline
Article

23 Metrics Mapped to the Product Life Cycle

Learn what to measure and how to avoid vanity metrics during each stage of the product life cycle: development, launch, growth, maturity and decline. Also learn the difference between a mission and objective and how to identify which stage your product is in.

Sign up to stay up to date on the latest industry best practices.

Sign up to received invites to upcoming webinars, updates on our recent podcast episodes and the latest on industry best practices.

Training on Your Schedule

Fill out the form today and our sales team will help you schedule your private Pragmatic training today.

Subscribe

Subscribe

Training on Your Schedule

Fill out the form today and our sales team will help you schedule your private Pragmatic training today.